It's a question that has come up several times online over the past few years: "why do carousel horses have open mouths?"
It may come as a surprise that this simple question is quite controversial. In fact, more than once it has generated heated debates between carousel lovers and real horse lovers--mostly due to how repetitive it has become.
Carousel horses typically have open mouths, as well as wide eyes and pinned ears, because it makes them much more energetic and dynamic. You may know of children that were initially frightened of carousel horses and thought it was odd that the horses on a children’s ride were carved to look somewhat scary. However, the carousel in fact originated as a thrill ride for adults, not as a tame ride for children, so expressive and even aggressive horses were better for attracting riders.
It is believed that the carousel originated from the Italian word ‘garosello’ or Spanish word ‘carosella,’ both meaning ‘little war,’ or the French word ‘carrousel,’ meaning ‘tournament.’ The carousel began as a hand-operated mechanism from which soldiers could practice spearing a hanging ring with their lances–it was a tool for training that eventually developed into an amusement for the nobility. The seats eventually evolved from simple benches or logs into wood-carved horses to further simulate horseback combat. This history may also contribute to the artistic decision to portray the horses as distressed, as they would be in the midst of battle.
In short, having more dramatic expressions was a decision fueled by the need to attract customers in order to compete with other manufacturers within the industry, making it both a financial and artistic choice.
But there lies the key to the infamous debate: carousel horses are art, and therefore cannot feel pain or distress. While this is common sense, this sentiment has become the crux of the arguments between carousel and horse people.
The trouble comes when horse owners protest or criticize carousel carvings for portraying animals in pain or distress. By feeling and expressing sympathy for the wooden horses, they unintentionally cast undue criticism onto the art and artists, which chafes at carousel enthusiasts who appreciate the pieces for the artistry.
But carousels are not the only places where horses are depicted as being distressed. Artwork from around the world, throughout history, has portrayed horses with similar expressions which likely inspired many carousel carvers. This includes, but is not limited to, sketches, paintings, and statues dating back over a thousand years.
It is also important to remember that many carousel figures were carved almost a century ago, when working animals like horses were often considered tools rather than valued as living beings, and long before animal rights activism as we know it today.
Modern carousel figures, both wood-carved, aluminum, and fiberglass, continue to honor the legacy of carousel animals by maintaining the wild, expressive looks. It is crucial that we understand that depicting an animal in pain in no way indicates that an artist supports animal cruelty.
There have been some extreme animal rights activists who have pushed carousel operators to have carousel horses recarved with closed mouths. This would completely ruin the original intent of the artist–akin to repainting the Mona Lisa to have a toothy grin. Antique carousels are already an endangered attraction, with many having been lost over the years to fires, floods, and the auction block. Organizations like the National Carousel Association (NCA) have worked hard to preserve the existing carousels, spending both time and money to keep them well-maintained and accessible for the public to enjoy as they have been for over a hundred years.
This isn’t to say that animal rights advocates are wrong! In fact, I myself feel strongly about animal welfare and in the past have volunteered at an animal shelter. However, I feel that there are effective ways to campaign against animal abuse, and ineffective ways.
I believe that the time, effort, and funding of animal rights activists and groups is better spent taking real, tangible action–assisting in the fostering and adoption of animals, funding rescues and shelters, and lobbying against unethical breeders, institutions, and individuals.
Spending time arguing about wooden horses while real, living horses are suffering can only be described as a waste of not only time but energy that could be better spent towards improving the welfare of actual animals. I truly encourage anyone interested in animal welfare to donate to reputable shelters and organizations, such as the ASPCA or your local rescue. They are always in need of donations (both monetary and in the form of supplies) and volunteers!